Is there a publication containing this obvious fact: For any real T>0, any natural n, any complex c1,…,cn, and any distinct complex z1,…,zn such that ∑n1cketzk=0 for all t∈[0,T), we have c1=⋯=cn=0?
Somehow, I cannot find such a publication.
Is there a publication containing this obvious fact: For any real T>0, any natural n, any complex c1,…,cn, and any distinct complex z1,…,zn such that ∑n1cketzk=0 for all t∈[0,T), we have c1=⋯=cn=0?
Somehow, I cannot find such a publication.
I will recount the more general statement of linear independence of characters, given in Lang's Algebra book, and credited to Artin. Let G be a group, and K a field. Then distinct homomorphisms ϕ1,…,ϕn:G→K× are linearly independent.
Proof: Suppose not, and suppose we have a nontrivial linear relation
a1ϕ1+…+anϕn=0,(1)
where n is taken as small as possible. Clearly n>1 and ai≠0 for all i. Because the ϕi are distinct, we can find an element g∈G such that ϕ1(g)≠ϕ2(g). We have
a1ϕ1(gh)+a2ϕ2(gh)+…+anϕn(gh)=0
for all h∈G; by virtue of the ϕi being homomorphisms, this may be rewritten to say
a1ϕ1(g)ϕ1+a2ϕ2(g)ϕ2+…+anϕn(g)ϕn=0,(2)
Dividing (2) by ϕ1(g) and then subtracting (1) from the result, we arrive at a linear relation
(a2ϕ2(g)ϕ1(g)−a2)ϕ2+…=0
which has fewer than n summands and is nontrivial by choice of g, contradiction. ◻
Let yk(t)=etzk. Proving by contradiction, suppose that they are linearly dependent, that is n∑k=1ckyk≡0. Differentiating n−1 times we obtain a homogeneous system of linear equations with respect to ck. To have a non-trivial solution, this system must have non-zero determinant. The determinant is: |y1y2…yny′1y′2…y′n…………y(n−1)1y(n−1)2…y(n−1)n|=A(t)|11…1z1z2…zn…………zn−11zn−12…zn−1n|, where A(t)=et(z1+…+zn)≠0. The determinant in the right hand side is easy to compute. Consider it as a polynomial with respect to, zn. It is evidently of degree n−1 and has n−1 roots at z1,…,zn−1. Therefore it is of the corm C(z1,…,zn−1)(zn−z1)…(zn−zn−1). Looking at the top degree term, we conclude that C is a similar polynomial. So by induction our determinant is ∏i<k(zi−zk). this is never zero, since zk are distinct.
References. Polya Szego, Problems and theorems of analysis, vol II, Part 7, "Determinants and quadratic forms''. Computation of the Vandermonde determinant is problem 2. The Wronskian criterion of linear independence is problem 60.
Remark. Vandermondes's determinant is computed in ANY undergraduate textbook of linear algebra, as a first example of determinant. For example, I teach linear algebra with the textbook of Strang, and differential equations with the textbook of Boyce and di Prima. Both of them have Vandermonde determinant.
Remark 2. Undergraduate textbooks are rarely freely available online. If you insist on a free online reference, you may refer on the proof above.