5

Why the intensity of light is more around the region of hot air around the flame of candle in the shadow cast by the light from the collimated source ?

enter image description here

Most of the articles mention it is due to the refraction of light through hot air around the candle's flame. But I'm unable to understand how refraction make this happen.

Curious
  • 135

2 Answers2

9

The column of warm air has lower density and thus lower refractive index. This makes a cylinder of low refractive index which acts as a lens wi h a negative focal length.

Light that would have passed through the column is bent outwards, where it is added to the light that was already there. So there is a dark region directly behind the cylinder, and a brighter rim right outside it.

I hope the following diagram makes it clear:

enter image description here

Incidentally, the refractive index of air is quite small: 1.0002772 (at 15 °C, 1 atm). You can expect this to scale roughly with density, so if you heat the air to about 300 °C, the density drops by a factor 2x and the change in $n$ is roughly 0.00014, or 0.014%. We can estimate the focal length of a column of air that is 2 mm diameter and 300 °C:

The focal length is approximately given by

$$f = \frac{R}{\Delta n}$$

which is a simplification of the lensmaker's equation

Putting in the numbers I estimated above, we find $f = \frac{1 mm}{0.00014}= 7 m$

This means that the bright fringe will be best observed if the screen is a few meters away from the candle; if you get much beyond the focal length, the effect will start to diminish again. If the column of hot air is smaller, the focal length will come closer; the same will happen if the air is hotter.

Note that if the incident source is extended (that is, light is arriving from multiple directions), then this tends to "smear out" any effect - which is why this is most visible if you use a point (or slit) source.

Floris
  • 118,905
  • Don't the light rays refract while leaving the cylinder of hot air? – Curious Feb 22 '16 at 01:40
  • @Curious - you are right; the drawing had a very small angle at the exit; I made it a bit bigger to clarify. It is a sketch, but a sketch should reproduce the critical features. Thanks for pointing it out. – Floris Feb 22 '16 at 14:45
  • Why is the above of the shadow in the picture of the question body so chaotic? – Snack Exchange Jul 22 '23 at 13:05
  • @SnackExchange - turbulent flow... I believe this transition from laminar to turbulent flow in the candle "heat plume" is called the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. – Floris Aug 11 '23 at 16:22
1

My gut reaction for the answer as to what causes this phenomena is that the candle's flame adjusts the index of refraction around the candle in two ways.

For one, heat is well known to cause refraction in a medium- you need only compare it to a mirage to see the similarities. As in the hazy image you'll find in a mirage caused by layers of hot air, roughly the same convective processes are going on in the heat around a burning candle- a gradient in the refractive index of the medium around the candle and the candle's surroundings. Lower index near the flame, higher surrounding the candle.

Additionally, flame needs oxygen to burn, and this intake of fuel removes some physical material- if you had pure oxygen around the flame, you could roughly create a vacuum in this way, after removing the products of combustion. I don't know exactly what effect this has, but would be willing to bet it would also lower the refractive index around the candle's flame, if only mildly.

  • I just looked it up- the difference in index of refraction of air at STP and nitrogen gas at STP is fairly negligible. – swickrotation Feb 21 '16 at 08:20
  • 1
    But is that "negligible difference due to composition" comparable to the change due to the difference in temperature? – Farcher Feb 21 '16 at 08:59