0

The title completely expresses the question. I have come across for several times the mixed tensors where the lower index is written closer to the tensor symbol and the upper index is written a bit farther away, like: $T_a \ ^b$. It also sometimes appeared in the other way around, as in: $T^b \ _a$. What's the difference?

In case of higher rank tensors, what's the difference between: $$T^a\ _{bc},\quad T_b\ ^a\ _c, \quad and \quad T_{bc} \ ^a$$

Qmechanic
  • 201,751
kada mati
  • 103

1 Answers1

1

When it comes to nonsymmetric tensors, the order of indices matter, even between covariant and contravariant indices. Let us take the difference between $T^a{}_b$ and $T_b{}^a$, multiplied by the metric $g_{ab}$ to raise and lower indices:

$$g_{ac}(T^a{}_b-T_b{}^a)=g_{ac}T^a{}_b-g_{ac}T_b{}^a=T_{cb}-T_{bc},$$

which is zero only if $T_{bc}=T_{cb}$, i.e., if $T$ is a symmetric tensor.

Higher rank tensors are harder to represent explicitly, but the idea is the same: e.g., $g_{ad}(T^a{}_{bc}-T_b{}^a{}_c)=T_{dbc}-T_{bdc}\ne 0$ unless $T$ is symmetric in its first two indices.

This becomes especially relevant in practice when one deals with the indices of the Riemann curvature tensor, for instance.

Viktor Toth
  • 1,863