1

This question follows the lead of a previous question (What kind of fluid is sand?), where basic properties of sand were discussed.

A comment to that same question linked to a videoclip where sand was made behave as a fluid by blowing some air through it from below.

My understanding is that the ripples and all the fluid-like features are consequence of a large amount of air being trapped underneath the grains of sand and flowing upwards so to make grains float.

Moreover I would explain the fact that air can percolate almost homogeneously through the sand by observing that the percolation will tend to follow layers of equal pressure in the sand, so that air will end up dispersing through al the width of the sand box before finally escaping from the sand. I am not very convinced by this, so any comment and clarification is appreciated.

The real question is different though: in the video it is shown that at some points, when the airflow increases sufficiently, the sand begins bubbling and air escapes through large bubbles.

The presence of bubbles means that there is a surface tension between the "liquid sand" and air.

I can understand ripples and vortexes since they are present in pure air too, but I would not associate surface tension to neither of sand and air.

So how can a mixture of gas and solid (air and sand) exhibit surface tension?

AoZora
  • 1,874
  • 2
    I say that bubbles do not necessarily mean existence of a surface tension. Moving sand is one of the nastiest problem in physics. We should not look too much at it, have fun and feel strong with simple black holes instead. – patta May 13 '19 at 15:41
  • 1
    Found this video, bubbles from the side: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcNuxk8vDu8 – patta May 13 '19 at 16:13
  • :) BHs till the big crunch! These bubbles stirred my interest because the possibility to introduce some sort of effective surface tension could have analogues in very far areas of physics.. – AoZora May 13 '19 at 16:18
  • "instability of fluidized beds" give a lot of papers that try to explain when bubbling occur. I tried to figure out a model myself but no success. Effective surface tension, that will be fun, you may get it for some regimes – patta May 14 '19 at 09:00
  • From one of the papers, say that for particles smaller than 60 microns the particle contact force ("true surface tension") plays a role – patta May 14 '19 at 09:08
  • 1
    Yeah I looked at some of those papers, like Sundaresan INSTABILITIES IN FLUIDIZED BEDS. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics (2003), but the studies are very quantitative and I cannot understand very well how they build this model of fluidized beds. I am thinking that maybe bubbles in this case are just the result of the isotropy of pressure in their content and (approximately) in their surrounding. – AoZora May 14 '19 at 09:54
  • Foscolo & Gibilaro 1984 -1987, Foscolo still alive at L'Aquila http://www.ing.univaq.it/cdl/scheda_corso.php?codice=I2H025 – patta May 15 '19 at 09:41
  • R Jackson, 1963, The Mechanics of Fluidized Beds: Part I , deceased and impossible to find the book ---- GK Batchelor, 1988, A New Theory of the Instability of a Uniform Fluidized Bed, deceased and impossible to find the paper – patta May 15 '19 at 09:43
  • The super book by Batchelor, "introduction to fluid dynamycs", I think has some paragraph on Sedimentation that is more or less a fluidized bed – patta May 15 '19 at 09:45
  • Mi colleague Mark suggested a mechanism for "surface tension" attraction: Bernoulli force; when you blow air between two grains, it must accelerate, thus decrease pressure (like when you blow between two sheets of paper, they get attracted each other). He says to put this force/potential in a Van der Waals model – patta May 15 '19 at 09:48
  • But sorry, I haven't read through any of those paper, nor Sundaresan 2003 – patta May 15 '19 at 09:51

0 Answers0