10

I don't understand how convection ovens can cook food faster than radiant heat ovens. Guides to convection ovens claim that they cook food 25-30% faster than radiant heat ovens, but do not really explain the physics of it.

For example, let's say we have a big turkey. Now, we surround the turkey with air heated to 350F, that is convection cooking. The air transfers its heat by contact to the turkey.

In contrast, if we roast the turkey, we have a red-hot heating element at 1200F radiating the top of the turkey. To test this I put some chicken in the oven and right next to it a block of wood. Both were about 12 inches from the heating element. After some time, the surface of the chicken was 250F and the surface of the wood was 450F. I am not sure why there is a difference, or why having air at 350F would cook the chicken faster than the radiant method. If the top of the chicken is 250F, I would expect the diffusion of the heat from the top of the chicken to be more rapid than if it is convected by air, but I guess this must be wrong for some reason, but I don't know the reason.

Ambrose Swasey
  • 4,474
  • 3
    The convection oven actively blows hot air to maximize heat transfer. – Jon Custer May 15 '22 at 17:49
  • @JonCuster I know how it works. The question is why this type of heat transfer would be more effective than radiative transfer. – Ambrose Swasey May 15 '22 at 17:51
  • 2
    @AmbroseSwasey It's not about one method being more or less effective. It's about using more methods at your disposal. Convection ovens also heat the food using radiating heat elements. It's not like convection ovens have a separate air heating chamber from the food and then that hot air is blown into the food chamber. Radiant heat also has shadows and is affected by emissivity of the material. – DKNguyen May 16 '22 at 15:26
  • Closely related: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/378170/226902 and https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/308237/226902 – Quillo Mar 28 '23 at 10:46

3 Answers3

22

For example, let's say we have a big turkey. Now, we surround the turkey with air heated to 350F, that is convection cooking. The air transfers its heat by contact to the turkey.

This is what we would typically call roasting in a conventional oven. When the turkey absorbs heat from the surrounding air, the air cools down; because air is a very bad conductor of heat, the (still) air develops a temperature gradient near the turkey which means that the air that the turkey is actually in contact with is substantially below $350^\circ$.

If we equip the oven with a fan system which circulates hot air to ensure that this layer of cool air near the turkey does not develop, then this is what we would call roasting in a convection (sometimes called fan-assisted) oven. Obviously this will cook the turkey faster because the air in contact with the turkey will actually be $350^\circ$, in contrast to the conventional oven.

In both of these cases, we are not cooking the turkey via the radiant heat from the (extremely hot) heating element. The heating elements are cycled on and off to maintain the temperature inside the oven, but they spend most of their time off. If we do cook with the radiant heat from the heating element, we keep the heating element on the whole time; this type of cooking is called either broiling or grilling, depending on where you live.

To test this I put some chicken in the oven and right next to it a block of wood. Both were about 12 inches from the heating element. After some time, the surface of the chicken was 250F and the surface of the wood was 450F.

Wood is dry, chicken is not. Water has a massive heat capacity - far larger than wood or almost anything else we use in a kitchen - which means it takes a lot of energy to raise the temperature of something which has a lot of water in it. The surface of the chicken is in direct contact with the interior of the chicken, which keeps it cool.

J. Murray
  • 69,036
  • 2
    Addition to the last paragraph: Wood is also quite an effective insulator. As such, only a very thin skin is actually heated up by the radiation since the heat takes a lot of time to diffuse into the wood proper. Of course, foods usually are not exactly good thermal conductors either, which is the whole reason why cooking massive things takes so long. You can heat a soup pretty much at any speed that your stove allows, but you cannot get a lasagne done in less than an hour, or so. Simply because the soup distributes heat quickly by convection which the lasagne cannot do. – cmaster - reinstate monica May 16 '22 at 09:02
  • 5
    "Broiling" is called "grilling" in international English, just to note! – Chris Melville May 16 '22 at 09:03
  • 1
    And a convection oven is usually called a 'fan oven' in British English (and presumably some other places as well), which helps avoid confusion with 'convection' the type of flow. – dbmag9 May 16 '22 at 13:06
  • @Chris Thanks for your note, I've edited that in to my answer. – J. Murray May 16 '22 at 15:15
  • 2
    @dbmag9 Thanks for your note, I've edited my answer. However, I would note that convection (energy transfer via the bulk flow of a fluid) is precisely the principle at work here - though it would be somewhat more accurate to say forced convection, because natural convection occurs in a conventional oven too. – J. Murray May 16 '22 at 15:21
1

I don't understand how convection ovens can cook food faster than radiant heat ovens.

Do you understand wind-chill?

They're essentially the same phenomenon -- forced convection, in which fluid motion is generated by an external source. (Yes, there are often some evaporative cooling effects alongside this, but let's neglect those for now.)

The physics of it are explained by Newton's law of cooling, which states that the rate of heat loss of a body is directly proportional to the difference in the temperatures between the body and its environment.

The forced convection disturbs the boundary layer of cooler air next to the raw chicken, so hotter air is in contact with the food longer -- and as the rate of thermal energy transfer is greater when the temperature difference between the air and the food is greater, the food cooks quicker.

Roger
  • 129
0

I have had a number of convection ovens and find the claim to be false. The oven heating elements (except the broiler) are shielded from the food and all heat transfer to the food is either convection directly to the food or convection to the pan/rack and conduction to the food in both types of oven. Having the fan circulating air makes the oven cook more evenly as you are less likely to have a region where the air is cooled by contact with the food. This must cause faster cooking, but it is not significant. I would never go back to one without a fan, but it is not cooking time that motivates me.

Ross Millikan
  • 8,520
  • 1
  • 21
  • 22